Відео

The band is very real. I can't say the same for your reaction.

Check out an earlier song of Floor Jansen's from her band "Ever After", Floor was only 21 years old @ the time in the performance below & her vocal's were already Amazing back then: "Monolith of Doubt": ua-cam.com/video/3TmKHkQx45U/v-deo.html

Mark just auctioned off his collection of finger picks for charity. It raised millions.

Slivovica?? 😀

There's a lot of debate when it comes to Tarja vs Floor. They're both incredible, but the one thing I'll say is that Floor can sing all of Tarja's songs. I doubt Tarja could sing all of Floor's.

I'm a long time DS and MK fan, and Mark record almost all the song playing live as you said. And Guy Flercher tells that the first take is almost always the best one. Think about what a bunch of amazing musicians are them!!!!

Floor can seemingly do any style or color she wants. It shows her versatility. I'm not a big fan of the operatic sound where you can't understand the lyrics and it just sounds muddy. It's usually not in good timing either for some reason. Floor has trained hard to overcome all of those issues.

Have you discovered them?😊enjoy their heavinly music❤

Just as John Bonham KNEW the "power of the pause" on the drums, so the master David Gilmour understands the "squeezing of each note"- when to attack, when to release, & his understanding of "intervals" between notes is simply amazing: how he uses those intervals to "lift or hold" you in the melody. He's truly in a class by himself.... & a humble man. I love you, David Gilmour-you're my guitar hero! Thanks for posting, Bro'!

Mark searched all over London to find traditional gut strings instead of nylon, specifically for this song.

I think watching Tarja Turunen perform Ghost Love Score would be a great idea! The song was written with her voice and style in mind, but I would agree that she leans more operatic than Floor Jansen does.

I don't enjoy his music, which is all that matters to me. He attracts a lot of chin-rubbers too, which makes him seem inauthentic. That's not his fault, but his fans can be annoying. I like artists that experiment, but I just don't like his results. He's got a long road ahead, though - I'm sure he'll bang out something I like one day!

did you think he is ready for poet and the pendulum or the greatest show on earth ?

The last time this was and will be played live right here. Classic great. Gilmour won’t play it without Rick and that’s perfect.

Note also that much of the piece is a back-and-forth conversation between the guitar and the keyboards :)

It's funny that your 'band leader' thought Jacob's music was out-of-tune given that Jacob has perfect pitch and your band leader obviously, does not. People said the same thing about Stravinsky and Mozart. "Too many notes!" Lol. Mozart didn't use too many notes and Collier doesn't use too many harmonies. Your ears just haven't evolved enough. Future generations will have no problems with his harmonies.

Good music touches the soul, this bring a tear.

OMG the best part was on the way after it comes out of the spacey part. The music returns. You only heard about 2/3 of the song. Please listen to it again or Pink Floyd Echoes Gdansk. Ahhh!! 😬

the drummer is a genius

1983

oh tegeltje... not even worth it.

You have Phil Manzanera lead guitarist of Roxy Music on second lead. And yes Roger said he ‘couldn’t be arsed’ to sue Lloyd Webber for the flagrant steal of the bass theme. This is a masterpiece and I was present at the birth and introduced the band onstage for their warm-up prior to their ‘world premiere’ of the Meddle album. David is wearing the Hendrix guitar strap that he bought and often uses.

Best is Gdańsk - the very last time it was played the last 5 minutes are extremely moving as David and Rick trade licks. But you didn’t get to the end! The end is the best part!

Echoes is from 1971. Phanton of the Opera 1985

Congrats bro, you are also a true musician and artist. What you just noticed in Mark's solo is exactly what he said about solos as a tip, "it must tell a story"

Final cut would be great 😊

Yes, the same descending scale as the Phantom of the Opera (from 1986). However, this song was written in 1971, so Andrew Lloyd Webber 'borrowed' this progression from Pink Floyd.

This is not Pink Floyd but Gilmour band

You stopped before the song was over! There's another incredible instrumental part and the final verse AFTER the ProgRock psychedelic sounds. The beginning of the psychedelic sounds is the beginning of "Echoes" Part 2. You stopped in the middle of the song! No one should ever do that with Pink Floyd. This performance of "Echoes" is both parts 1 and 2 consecutively, unlike the 1971 recording on Pink Floyds 6th album "Echoes", where it was broken up into 2 separate parts. This performance has a very special significance, over all these years this was a special song for Dave Gilmour and Rick Wright, together exclusively, they sang the harmony over all these decades. This performance in 2006 was the last time the song was ever performed as Richard Wright died two years later from cancer. David Gilmour said after Wrights death,... he would never perform the song again. Andrew Lloyd Weber ripped off Pink Floyd with that riff, in fact Roger Waters had considered suing Weber but decided against it. The riff, chords and notes are C#m to A maj chords, walking down the notes,... C#, C, B, Bb, landing on A, then walking back up again to C#.

Solid reaction to this one, even though it's an incomplete video. It's not your fault, whoever uploaded this should be ashamed. lol The official version of this particular show is one long composition. I personally love the Remember That Night DVD as a whole more than the Live At Gdansk DVD (both 2006), but I prefer the Gdansk version of Echoes. There are 3 essential versions of Echoes. The original studio version, the Live At Pompeii version from 1972, and the Gdansk which incorporates the best elements of the other two into one. I would rate this as the fourth best version. Also, Echoes was released in 1971, and I believe ALW did the music for Phantom in 1974, '75, or '76. He absolutely stole the main riff from Floyd.

This is david's favorite venue to play BTW best song ever written! I don't know if you knew this, but the guitar strap.He's wearing belonged to Jimi Hendrix.His wife polly bought it for him for his birthday

Richard Stilgoe(author of phantom opera theme) tried to buy echoes song to use in the movie but he was rejected, then he stoled the melody but pin floyd members said that he is too pathetic to sue him

no way that you watched this live first! The live at pompeii 1972 is 100000 times better, you should listen to it there so many going on!!

Great reaction. Anyway, can i request your reaction to superb band from japan? The band is call "Lovebites" They all The Beautiful Queens Metal band right now in the earth. They are really really World class musicians. Phenomenal. And they have a lot die hard fans too. The song is "Swang song with chopin intro" Hope you check out, and can enjoy it too. Big thanks🙏

No effects honey!!! Ive seen it live.

Dave Gilmour does seem to use alot of bends in his playing and some really big stretches. Think because the human brain picks up the curve rather than the step it just ramps up the emotional aspect to such a high level. And not only does he do that alot, he never misses where he's going, even with those really big bends he just seems to nail it perfectly.

Yes Lloyd Webber pinched it! 😂

Plug your guitar into the OUTput of a wah wah pedal and the OUTput cable into the input hole and using the volume knob and pedal you will get feedback that sounds like seagulls screeching which Gilmour controls with his feet and control knobs. You should try it!

Wheres the other 7 minutes

You missed the 2nd half.

Wow there are some short comments on this vid.. If you liked it im happy, dont worry about the commenters👍👍👍

I understand this was a paid request, but it was a bad choice of either specific video, or the concert. The song is some 23:30 long and was the entire side of the album Meddle. This video cut it short by a substantial amount, and honestly the performance was poor compared to other ones. Even other ones by this grouping alongside David the Rick, such as their performance in Gdansk. Please consider re doing it with a better version, as it is epic in the sonic journeyL ua-cam.com/video/EMneCi9F_UQ/v-deo.html ( David Gilmour - Echoes (Live In Gdańsk) ) The quality of the recording and playing is infinitely better than the version you watched. And this is one of the last times it was performed by David and Richard, as Richard passed away shortly after this concert. David refuses to play the song anymore without Richard on keys. And their combined outro is simply sublime....

I’ve heard Knopfler compared to Gilmour before. Love them both but only recently have been able to discern the similarities in their styles. The biggest difference between them are the effects and reverb that David uses. But Gilmour was doing this before Knopfler. This is from 1971! Anyway as someone else mentioned, the second half of this song is the best part.

Nightwish Army Germany calling. Welcome to the World of Nightwish 😊

Great! Where is the rest of the song?

David was keeping it funky!

Oh, bad luck : this video cuts before the song comes back from the crazyness (and David Gilmour doing seagulls sounds with his guitar) into the final part of the song. This part, with all the instrument coming back progressively until the sound explodes is the best. Try the studio version on Meddle album, the best for me, or the live at Pompeii (full version), which is also incredible.

Oh gees, another limp video that some one has suggested that it closely resembles the ORIGINAL audio version. NOTHING comes close to the audio version !!!! Oh I can't watch. it['s bastardising the original mix and melody...🤯

I love this band, and I adore Floor Jansen. She's the bomb.

Pink Floyd wrote this song far ealier, than Webber wrote "The Phantom of the Opera", so he simply stole their theme.